Wednesday 25 May 2011

The Mistake That Bugs He & I

Okay, so I tend to agree with the argument made here... but hang on a moment. It's far from watertight. 

So fine, it'd be stupid to say 'me tend to agree'; which does seem to lead to the conclusion that 'Jim and me tend to agree' should be wrong, and it ought to be 'Jim and I tend to agree'.

Right?

But who's to say that 'compound subjects' don't follow different rules? They're not exactly the same as singular ones; they're plural. It'd be equally silly to say 'Jim and I is right', or 'Jim and I am right' - it's 'Jim and I are right', right?  (Or is it 'Jim and me are right'...?)

Have a read and see what you think.